Hair Damage Risk Calculator

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you.

How to Use This Calculator

Assessing your hair damage risk takes just four quick questions:

1. Your primary accessory: Select what you use most often—elastic ties, scrunchies, claw clips, bobby pins, headbands, or barrettes. Each has a different baseline damage potential.
2. Usage frequency: How often do you wear this accessory? Daily use compounds damage over time; occasional use is more forgiving.
3. Hair condition: Healthy hair withstands more stress than damaged or fragile hair. Be honest about your current hair health.
4. Visible breakage: Do you notice short broken hairs where you typically place your tie or clip? This is a key damage indicator.

Once you complete all questions, click "Assess My Risk" to see your damage score and personalized recommendations.

Understanding Your Results

Your results provide a comprehensive damage assessment:

• Damage score (1-10): Higher scores indicate greater damage risk. This considers your accessory type, frequency, hair condition, and visible damage signs.
• Risk level: Your score translates to Low (1-3), Moderate (4-5), Elevated (6-7), or High (8-10) risk categories.
• Damage comparison chart: See how different accessory types compare on the damage scale.
• Personalized recommendations: Specific tips based on your inputs and score to reduce damage going forward.

If your score is concerning, don't worry—damage from hair accessories is usually reversible once you switch to gentler options like claw clips or silk scrunchies.

Is Your Hair Accessory Secretly Damaging Your Hair?

That ponytail holder you use every day might be doing more harm than you realize. If you've noticed a ring of shorter, broken hairs around your hairline—or strands snapping off where you typically place your hair tie—you're not imagining things.

Hair accessory damage is real, cumulative, and often preventable. Our calculator above assesses your current risk level and recommends gentler alternatives. Let's dive into the science of why some accessories damage hair—and which ones don't.

How Hair Damage Happens

Hair damage from accessories comes from three main forces:

Friction

Every time you remove a hair tie, it creates friction against your strands. Rubber and elastic materials have high friction coefficients—they grip hair tightly, which is good for hold but bad for hair health. Over time, this friction wears down the hair cuticle (the protective outer layer), leading to dryness, frizz, and breakage.

Tension

Tight ponytails and buns create constant pulling force on your hair follicles. This tension can lead to traction alopecia—hair loss caused by repeated pulling. The damage typically appears at the hairline and temples first, since these areas bear the most strain.

Pressure Points

Hard clips and accessories that clamp down create concentrated pressure. If you always wear your clip in the same spot, you may notice breakage specifically at that location.

Hair Accessory Damage Rankings

Based on friction, tension, and breakage potential, here's how common hair accessories compare:

High Damage Risk (Score 7-10)

• Rubber bands: The worst offenders. High friction, high tension, and difficult to remove without yanking hair.
• Thin elastic hair ties: Standard drugstore elastics create a tight grip that stresses hair at the tie line.
• Metal hair ties with clasps: Can catch and snap individual hairs when clasping/unclasping.

Moderate Damage Risk (Score 4-6)

• Fabric scrunchies: Softer than elastics, but still create friction. Better for occasional use.
• Metal bobby pins: Can scratch the scalp and snag hair, especially when bent or worn.
• Plastic headbands: Depend on design—some create significant pressure behind the ears.

Low Damage Risk (Score 1-3)

• Claw clips: Distribute pressure across teeth, no tight elastic tension. Stylists recommend them for daily wear.
• Silk/satin scrunchies: Minimal friction due to smooth fabric. Great for sleeping.
• Acetate barrettes: Smooth, non-snagging surface. Gentle on hair.
• Coated bobby pins: Rubber tips prevent scratching and snagging.

Why Claw Clips Are Gentler

Claw clips consistently rank as one of the gentlest hair accessory options. Here's why:

• No elastic tension: Unlike hair ties, claw clips don't stretch around your hair and create constant pulling force.
• Distributed pressure: The teeth of a claw clip spread the holding force across a larger area, rather than concentrating it in one line.
• Easy removal: Open the clip, and your hair releases freely—no friction from sliding a tie off.
• Adjustable grip: You control how much hair goes in and how tightly it's held.

This doesn't mean claw clips can't cause damage—improper use still matters. Using a clip that's too small for your hair, clamping too tightly, or always placing the clip in the exact same spot can still cause problems over time.

Use our clip size calculator to find the right size for your hair type.

Signs Your Accessories Are Damaging Your Hair

Watch for these warning signs:

• Breakage at the "tie line": Short, broken hairs that form a halo where you typically place your ponytail
• Thinning at the hairline: Especially at the temples where tension is highest
• Dents or crimps: Visible lines where your tie was—if they don't bounce back quickly, you're causing structural damage
• Excessive shedding when removing accessories: Some shedding is normal, but clumps indicate a problem
• Scalp tenderness: Pain where your clip or tie sits means you're creating too much tension

Reducing Hair Damage: Practical Strategies

Here's how to protect your hair while still styling it:

Switch to Gentler Options

The single biggest change you can make is replacing elastic hair ties with claw clips or silk scrunchies for daily wear. Reserve elastics for workouts when you need maximum security.

The Slip Silk Scrunchies are excellent for everyday use and sleeping—the silk reduces friction significantly compared to cotton or velvet scrunchies.

Vary Your Styles

Don't wear your hair the same way every day. Alternate between high ponytails, low buns, half-up styles, and wearing your hair down. This prevents consistent stress on any one area.

Loosen Up

Your style doesn't need to be ballet-bun tight. Slightly looser styles still look polished and dramatically reduce tension on your follicles.

Rest Your Hair

Let your hair down for at least part of each day. Overnight is ideal—sleeping with your hair loose (or in a very loose silk scrunchie) gives your scalp and strands time to recover.

Replace Worn Accessories

Stretched-out elastics grip less effectively, so you pull them tighter—increasing damage. Bent bobby pins snag hair. Clips with worn teeth don't hold as well. Use our replacement calculator to know when it's time for new accessories.

Special Considerations by Hair Type

Fine or Thinning Hair

Fine hair is especially vulnerable to damage because each strand is thinner and weaker. Use the gentlest options possible—silk scrunchies, small acetate clips, and coated bobby pins. Avoid tight styles entirely.

Curly or Textured Hair

Curly hair is more fragile due to its structure—each curl point is a potential weak spot. Wide-tooth claw clips designed for curly hair help prevent snagging and flattening.

Chemically Treated Hair

Color-treated, relaxed, or permed hair has a compromised cuticle layer. It's more susceptible to friction damage. Prioritize low-friction accessories like silk and acetate.

Long Hair

The longer your hair, the heavier it is—and the more strain you put on your scalp when pulling it up. Large claw clips designed for long hair distribute weight better than ponytails.

The Traction Alopecia Warning

If you're noticing consistent thinning at your hairline or temples, take it seriously. Traction alopecia starts as temporary hair loss but can become permanent if the damaging habits continue.

Early signs include:

• Receding hairline at temples
• Small bumps on the scalp where hair is being pulled
• Widening part line
• Hair that breaks off rather than grows to full length

If you're experiencing these symptoms, switch to gentle accessories immediately and consider consulting a dermatologist. The good news: caught early, traction alopecia is fully reversible.

Your Action Plan

Based on your damage risk score from the calculator above:

Score 1-3 (Low Risk)

Great news—your current accessories aren't causing significant damage. Maintain your current routine, but consider varying your styles to prevent future issues.

Score 4-6 (Moderate Risk)

Time to make some changes. Start replacing elastic ties with claw clips for daily use. Try silk scrunchies for loose holds. Our starter kit builder can help you build a gentler accessory collection.

Score 7-10 (High Risk)

Your current accessories are likely causing damage. Make an immediate switch to gentler options—claw clips, silk scrunchies, and coated bobby pins. Let your hair rest loose when possible. If you're noticing breakage or thinning, the sooner you act, the better.

Calculator Limitations

This calculator provides useful guidance, but keep these factors in mind:

• Individual variation: Hair damage tolerance varies significantly between people. Your genetics, diet, and overall health affect how your hair responds to stress.
• Not a diagnostic tool: This calculator estimates risk based on common patterns. It cannot diagnose actual damage—for that, consult a dermatologist or trichologist.
• Technique matters: How you use accessories affects damage as much as what you use. A gentle hand with elastic ties may cause less damage than rough handling of claw clips.
• Other factors exist: Heat styling, chemical treatments, and environmental exposure also cause damage. Accessories are just one piece of the puzzle.
• Quality varies: Not all accessories within a category are equal. Premium bobby pins with coated tips differ from cheap uncoated ones.

For bobby pin users specifically, our bobby pin calculator can help you determine the right quantity to avoid overuse.

Ready to Protect Your Hair?

Use the calculator above to assess your current risk level, then explore our clip size calculator to find the perfect gentle alternative for your hair type.

For more on whether claw clips are safe for daily wear, read our detailed analysis: Are Claw Clips Bad for Your Hair? Stylist Answers.